Is Howard Schultz An Authentic Leader?

Howard Schultz is a household name when it comes to Starbucks, but his style of leadership has caused controversy far beyond the coffee world. There are some who view him as a visionary dedicated to business values, but there are others who wonder if what he did actually showed the teachings of authenticity. A review of his leadership based on transparency, how he dealt with his employees, and how he addressed the general public gives the proof of whether or not Schultz was a genuine leader.

How Howard Schultz’s Leadership Style Reflects His Commitment To Company Culture

Perhaps Schultz's most well-documented trait is his dedication to creating a solid company culture, as he aimed to create a culture in which employees, whom he called "partners," would feel respected and cared for, providing healthcare benefits and stock options to even part-time workers as an early sign of his faith in corporate social responsibility. His leadership was based to a great extent on storytelling and emotional connection, creating relationships between employees and with clients as well, but corporate actions, like closing stores and laying off workers, sometimes seemed to conflict with these ideas and the question is whether or not his leadership ever aligned with the values he publicly espoused.

Also Check Out Our: Does Jeff Bezos Have Children?

The Public Persona Of Howard Schultz And His Engagement In Social And Political Issues

Schultz has never been afraid to weigh in on social and political issues, openly discussing topics like racial equality, healthcare, and immigration and making Starbucks a company that cares about more than just the bottom line. His 2018 move to shut down thousands of Starbucks stores for racial bias training showed a willingness to confront society's issues in the company, but although some respected his dedication to issues in the real world, others wondered if his actions were more about managing the brand than having actual concern. Authentic leadership is all about consistency, and critics have cited examples of Schultz's messaging being more image-protection for Starbucks than driving long-term change, but his capacity to have meaningful conversations definitely influenced the way people viewed him as a leader.

How Howard Schultz’s Treatment Of Employees And Business Decisions Affect His Leadership Image

Perhaps the most important thing about authentic leadership is how a leader conducts themselves towards employees in times of crisis. Schultz's image as a champion of employee welfare has been both celebrated and criticized because he instituted perks such as tuition reimbursement and full-coverage health care that distinguished Starbucks from rivals. But when Starbucks employees pushed to organize, his response was criticized, with accusations of anti-union propaganda, shutting down unionizing shops, and making claims against collective bargaining causing suspicions that he placed company over voice of employees. This was seen by some to be inconsistent with his long-established reputation as a values-driven leader who cared for his employees, which called into question whether or not his leadership ever modeled integrity and consistency of action in what he said and did.

Also Check Out Our: What Did Jeff Bezos Say About Space?

The Growth Of Starbucks Under Howard Schultz And His Strategic Leadership Decisions

During Schultz's tenure, Starbucks expanded into a global chain with thousands of stores across various continents, based on strategic moves like increasing product offerings and transforming store formats in order to further customer experience. His sense for consumer sentiment helped Starbucks become a place where one wanted to linger, not grab a coffee and leave. However, as Starbucks grew, hard business decisions could not be helped. Layoffs, price increases, and shifting corporate priorities sparked doubts whether Schultz's leadership style was ever true to the values he espoused, and if authenticity was ever the top concern in his decision-making.

Also Check Out Our: What Mindset Does Jeff Bezos Have?

Examining Whether Howard Schultz Truly Embodies The Definition Of An Authentic Leader

It is not possible to provide a straightforward answer to whether Schultz is a true leader or not. His professional life is full of instances when he demonstrated real concern for employees, customers, and social issues. However, some of his business actions and leadership choices were criticized and challenged his consistency.

Schultz's leadership is characterized by some of the attributes that are part of authenticity, including emotional connection, good communication, and commitment to core values. Then again, given the need to balance corporate interests and social values, his authenticity is questionable. Nonetheless, Schultz is a powerful leader whose legacy continues to provoke arguments related to leadership, corporate accountability, and business ethics.